|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Every new session of Parliament begins with a bill nobody intends to pass. Before the
Speech from the Throne is taken up, the House of Commons gives first reading to Bill C-1,
An Act respecting the Administration of Oaths of Office. It is never debated and never voted
on. It is read so the Commons can show that it may take up its own business before it
answers the Crown. The ritual makes a large point: a bill does not have to become law to
matter. Sometimes the reading is the point.
Which raises a question worth sitting with. What would a Haldimand bill look like? Not a
land claim, not a negotiation table, not another decade in the courts, but a plain statute that
says in writing what the Proclamation of 1784 means. Draft bills of exactly that kind, one
provincial and one federal, have been posted at www.mohreg.org/bills. Treat them as an
exercise in constitutional imagination. The interesting thing is not whether they pass. It is
what they reveal when you take them seriously.
Consider the precedent. In 1893 Ontario passed the Algonquin National Park Act, setting
apart a vast block of land by statute and spelling out what could and could not be done inside
it. It took one session, yet the same Province has gone more than 150 years without saying
plainly what the Grand River lands are. It is not short of power. The theory would be that it
has simply never been asked to use that power in this direction.
The comparison only goes so far. The Algonquin Act was the Province giving something. A
Haldimand bill, on this reasoning, would ask the Province to give nothing at all, on the
footing that the Grand River lands were never Ontario’s to give. When Ontario was made in
1867, section 109 of the Constitution Act passed the Crown’s lands to it subject to “any
Interest other than that of the Province in the same.” Read that way, those few words carry
the whole argument. Whatever Ontario received at Confederation came to it already
burdened with an interest that belonged to someone else, and section 52, which makes the
Constitution the supreme law, means no ordinary statute lifts that burden by being applied
for a long time.
Take the theory one step further and the map changes. The Proclamation set the lands at
six miles deep on each side of the river, from its mouth to its head. If that measure entered
the Constitution with the interest itself, then no surveyor or land board could redraw it. Yet
the lines on today’s maps come from a straight survey agreed in 1791: a centre line run from
a bend near the mouth to the Mohawk Village, with parallel limits six miles either side. The
Grand does not run straight, and a grant measured from its banks cannot be honoured with
a ruler. A bill built on the true six miles, measured from each bank and following every bend,
would take in ridings the straight survey leaves out, and members who have never thought of
themselves as representing Haldimand lands would find that they do.
What might such a bill contain? The drafts sketch an answer. Ontario and Canada would
honour section 109 and the exclusive use and enjoyment the Proclamation secured to the
Loyalist Mohawk of the three villages and their posterity. A named body, the Mohawk
Nation of Grand River, would act for the holders of that interest, so no minister could say
there is no one to talk to. Crown land in the Tract, once decommissioned, would return to
the Loyalist Mohawk, with the Nation deciding its use, not as a right of first refusal but as
the return of something never surrendered. Retired public equipment bought and worn out
on the Tract would follow the same path. Property in the Tract going to tax sale would pass
to the Nation.
That last idea is where any critic would aim first, and it holds up better than expected.
Nobody loses a home. A tax sale comes only after an owner has already lost the property to
the municipality. Nobody’s mortgage is cancelled. With public notice, every bank and buyer
in a foreclosure along the river would know of the interest, and a purchase by the Nation
would be a good-faith transfer made in the open. The standing objection to the Haldimand
interest has always been that honouring it would dispossess families who bought in good
faith. A bill drafted this way answers the objection by design.
The exercise also forces a look at 1793. In 1791 the promise was that a further instrument
would follow to settle the Grand River lands. Simcoe’s Patent of 1793 was offered as that
instrument, and the Grand River Mohawk never accepted it. If a grant refused by its
grantees does not become their deed simply because a Crown officer wrote it out, then the
Haldimand Proclamation stands on its own words, and everything later built on the Patent,
including the idea that this land is held for a band under the Indian Act, rests on a document
turned away at the door.
Notice too what such a bill would leave out. It would not say that Ontario law or Canadian
law reaches into the life of the Nation. It would set out a handover by stages, in which the
powers ministries now exercise on the Tract pass to the Nation’s own officers and systems,
with protection against interference and room for economic development. Reduced to its
core, it would ask the Crown to concede under section 52 what its own documents already
suggest: that it overstepped.
None of this would be aimed at the people of Brantford, Caledonia, Cambridge, Paris or
any other town on the river. They did not draft the Patent or run the registry, and most were
never told. The argument is with the Crown, which made a promise and then let its
provinces and registrars carry on as if it had not. The families in those houses deserve to
know what lies under their titles, just as the Mohawk deserve to hear it said aloud.
So what would a first reading achieve, if passage is a long road? The same thing C-1
achieves. A bill given first reading is printed, numbered and kept. It sits in the Journals and
in Hansard, where it cannot be denied or written off as rally talk. The next minister who says
there is no clear proposal on the table would find one there. The next judge who wonders
whether Parliament was ever asked would find that it was.
That is the thought experiment, and anyone can run it. The drafts are short. They take
nothing from anyone’s constituents and ask nothing of the treasury that the Crown did not
already owe. First reading would not require a member to agree with every line; second
reading and committee exist for that. It would require only the view that a promise made in
the King’s name deserves a hearing in the King’s Parliament. The Crown gave its word on
this river in 1784. The theory is simple: before anyone is asked to keep that word, someone
only has to read it aloud.
Read the draft bills at www.haldimandbills.org


